Double Parmesan: A Story of True Love and a Crisis Averted

About that 16-gallon cheese I mentioned in last week’s newsletter? The one I said wasn’t going very well? Well, it was a Parmesan, or two Parmesans rather: one made in the morning and one made in the afternoon. Since my Parms always end up on the thin side, I thought I could press one, then press the other, and then, once they were nice and squished, I could combine them in the same mold and press them together overnight.  

Wouldn’t you know, what with the spring grass and the higher fat milk, those Parms were way bigger than normal. So big, in fact, that there was no way I could combine them in the same mold. 

I tried, though!

And then I panicked. There may have been some yelling. Some almost-crying. 

But then my husband jumped into the fray.

He drilled some holes in a two-gallon milk bucket and, voilà, a new mold was born. 

Sometimes it pays to panic (wink).

The bucket mold isn’t actually ideal since the sides slope a bit too much and I didn’t have a follower that fit snug, but it got the job done. (Any of you have a good recommendation for a mold that fits 12-20 gallons of milk?)

I trimmed off the puffy edge and ate it.

I brined this monster — it weighs over 14 pounds — for two-plus days, and now I’m aging it in a big lidded tub at 55°F/13°C. Every couple days I wash it down with a light salt brine. 

Say cheese!

I showed my coworkers a photo of the cheese and their first response (after making bug eyes) was, “You should cut off the top and toss hot pasta in it!” And I was like, OH MY WORD YES. So maybe, just maybe, we might end up throwing one heck of a pasta party. Check back in 12 months!

Similar Posts

  • Printable Recipes Are Here!

    It’s been months in the making but finally, FINALLY, I have written recipes available for download! I made (with my brother’s help) a little store over on the Milkslinger website. It’s super basic, but for now it’s a start. Consider this a soft launch. Q&A So, Jennifer. Why the printed recipes?Videos are fabulous for teaching a…

  • The Butter Battle

    Making butter is a real chore. Hand cranking is for the birds, and a blender is slow going (the blender turns cream into butter in 5 minutes or less, but it requires constant tending, multiple batches, and is brutally loud), so for a couple years now, I’ve been pestering my husband to fashion me a…

  • Seriously Pressed

    A few weeks ago, YouTube follower Robert Samuelson sent me a handmade light-weight Dutch press. If you like it, great, he said, and if not, pass it on to someone else. Well, let me tell you, this cheese press isn’t going anywhere. This slender beauty has super pressure power (check out this video he did to test just how much weight the press could…

  • No More Camembert?

    “Did you hear the NPR report about Camembert?” my younger son said. “The mold that’s used to make it is going extinct.” “Oh, really?” I said, barely listening since the kid likes to frequently regale me with accounts of what he hears on the news, as well as the plots of various TV series, books,…